Bad Cover Version’s Bad Cover Versions: Coldplay’s “Cover” of Depeche Mode’s Video

September 9, 2008

It was almost immediately after last week’s intro to Bad Cover Version’s Bad Cover Versions that I completely randomly asked myself, “What are Depeche Mode doing these days?”  So, I toddled over to their website, where I saw that … wait… what?

Coldplay has done a “cover” of Depeche Mode’s video for “Enjoy the Silence.”  You know, the one where Dave Gahan wears a big, long, furry king’s mantle and crown, and walks about the countryside looking windswept and pretentious?  It’s supposed to be one of their videos that is “artsy,” directed by Anton Corbijn (who has photographed a lot of people, but perhaps none so iconically as Depeche Mode and U2).

Coldplay’s video is for “Viva La Vida,” one of their many songs suggestive of putting U2 in a blender with an orchestra and adding a little bit of the spirit–though not sound–of Dave Matthews.  They’re just slimy enough that you know Chris Martin is doing it not because he believes Coldplay are good, but because he knows that they will appeal to an audience that is relatively underserved but has lots of cash: those upwardly mobile, middle-class kids who have yet to develop real taste but know that taste exists, and so they play it safe with milquetoast music.

Copying Depeche Mode’s video–or, more precisely, Anton Corbijn’s visual style–is a move from the same dance.  Anton Corbijn’s photography is at once accessible and artistic, often featuring extraordinarily well known bands in very remote places.  And, as we all know, landscapes are “artistic.”

His series of videos for Depeche Mode were oftentimes a little bit weird in plot, but by no means visually assaulting.  Often filmed in grainy black and white, or alternately in bright, bleeding, oversaturated color, his videos for Depeche Mode often featured the band interacting with very sexy women (e.g. “Personal Jesus”).

In “Enjoy the Silence,” though, Corbijn made lead singer Dave Gahan the visual focus against the Swiss Alps, with shots of the whole band posing seductively randomly thrown in (Oh, and there were shots of that omnipresent Violator rose, too).  Supposedly, the video’s storyline alludes to The Little Prince.  But mostly it’s just a guy dressed as a king, walking around with a deck chair, who, according to Corbijn, was a man with everything in the world and just wanted a place to sit.

All of which brings me to Coldplay’s video.  The title and lyrics of the song “Viva La Vida” lend themselves easily to the kingly theme.  But, wait a minute: one thing that made the Depeche Mode video at least a little interesting was that it was completely random.  Dave Gahan is a king, wandering around with a deck chair?  OK, that’s kind of fun.  But with Coldplay, we have things spelled out for us, because we’re stupid and middlebrow and not that clever (or so Chris Martin thinks of us).

Also, Coldplay’s video puts the king in the city, looking lonely, and in town models, looking large, instead of in the windswept mountains.  Oh, and instead of carrying a chair, he’s got a painting.  Lacking the interest of “What the hell is he doing out in the Swiss Alps with a lawn chair?”, the video is pretty lame.  Also, if I were Corbijn, I’d also be up in arms about how poorly edited the whole thing is in comparison to the original.  Corbijn, though, actually directed the video, making it somehow a bit of an in-joke that I just don’t get.

Anyway, here’s the Coldplay version:

And Depeche Mode’s “Enjoy the Silence”:

NOTE: “ROCK HISTORY, WHAT I LEAVE OUT” RETURNS TOMORROW!  I just ran into a bit of a deadline here today in my real life.


3 Responses to “Bad Cover Version’s Bad Cover Versions: Coldplay’s “Cover” of Depeche Mode’s Video”

  1. Agent M said

    Wow…that kinda bums me out, seeing the Coldplay vid (with boring tune) and knowing Corbijn’s just treading over his own work.

  2. fiddlemethis said

    I don’t have time to watch the videos now, but speaking of cover versions–you’ve heard what Lacuna Coil did with “Enjoy the Silence,” right? To my ear, it’s maybe even an improvement (and I like the original a whole lot). But then, I guess I am just an ol’ closet Goth 😉

  3. Andrea said

    Only for you would I sit through a whole Coldplay song. Heh.
    Yeah, I think he should have left well enough alone. Perhaps it’s a subtle nod to how “second rate” he finds Coldplay’s music, because the singer in that video only gets a crap-ily made felt bauble version of the king’s mantle, where as Gahan actually had at least faux fur on his mantle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

I Will Start This Blog. I Mean It!

Adventures in cranky essays and rhyming poetry from an unlikely single mom.

musings on film, television, music, gender, identity, and everything in between...

The Seminar Table

learning / teaching / resisting


some of us are brave

modern disappointment.

A place to file your complaints. Submissions welcome.

Deb Werrlein


As the Adjunctiverse Turns

cheeky, no respect for academia

A Post-Academic in NYC

The PhD and Everything After


Wovon man nicht schweigen kann, darüber muss man sprechen.

when the devil leaves his porchlight on

Just another weblog is the best place for your personal blog or business site.

%d bloggers like this: